Why the Island’s future needs more than one basket, and why the Visitor Economy is critical to it.
Over the last few weeks, in three articles, I have argued that Jersey’s Visitor Economy is skilled, undervalued and all but absent from the two documents that will shape this Island for the next four years. This one steps back to look at the document that sits at the very top of this Government of Jersey‘s agenda, and that I suspect will shape the next decade far more than either of them, which is Time to Win, the final report of the Financial Services Competitiveness Programme, published in March.
Its importance is not in doubt. Implementing it is the first action under Priority 2 of the proposed Common Strategic Policy, the draft 2027 Budget includes targeted investment to deliver its roadmap, and the report itself sets out, with a frankness I admire, why the Island cannot afford to stand still. I understand that urgency entirely, because when one sector provides, on the report’s own figures, two in five jobs and £6 in every £10 of tax revenue, and that sector faces new competitors, new technology and a world that is redrawing the map for international capital, it would be negligent not to act.
My argument is not that Time to Win is wrong. Much of it is right, and I will say so. It is that delivering every word of it, which I hope this Government does, still will not give Jersey a secure future on its own, because the risk the report describes so well is a risk of concentration, and concentration cannot be cured by doubling down on the thing you are concentrated in. What Jersey needs alongside Time to Win is a diverse and balanced economy, with several engines working together, that delivers a quality of life Islanders actually feel, and the evidence suggests they do not yet feel it as strongly as they should. In that economy, I believe the Visitor Economy is not simply important. It is critical. Put more bluntly, the question this Island now needs to ask itself is whether Time to Win can actually win without us, and I do not believe it can.
What Time to Win gets right.
It is honest about the threat. The report says plainly that whilst Jersey’s financial and related professional services sector is growing, it is ‘losing ground in relative terms’, and its Independent Expert Panel, chaired by Sir Howard Davies, goes further, noting that Jersey has fallen to 31st in the Global Financial Centres Index, from 25th in 2024 and 13th in 2009. It is honest about the cause, which it finds not in any lack of quality but in friction, complexity and institutions whose responsibilities overlap so that ‘no one has been mandated to own the whole system’. It is honest, too, about what is at stake, because the sector’s success, in the panel’s words, ‘has funded public services that would otherwise have been impossible without higher rates of tax’.
It is right about the remedy as well. Faster decisions, less duplication, digital services that work, a welcoming front door for new business, targeted marketing that is measured against its return, and a Government that behaves as though it wants to win are not controversial ideas, and most of them would help every business on this Island, not only those in finance.
There is one passage I would ask every Minister to read again with our industry in mind: ‘Requirements accumulate, each individually defensible, collectively creating a system slower and more expensive than it needs to be. The question is not whether each rule has a rationale. It is whether anyone has been tasked with asking whether the cumulative effect is making Jersey less competitive.’
That is, almost word for word, the case this Association has been making about the cost base of hospitality for four years, and if it is the right diagnosis for finance, it is the right diagnosis for us.
The risk it cannot remove on its own.
Where I part company with the report is on what it can achieve by itself. Time to Win describes the finance sector as ‘the platform on which the Island’s living standards, public services and fiscal sustainability are built’, and it explains, fairly, that output per worker in the sector is nearly three times the average across the rest of the economy, so that replacing its contribution through other sectors ‘would be neither realistic nor sustainable’. I agree. Nobody serious is proposing to replace financial services, and I am certainly not.
The report’s own evidence, though, describes an Island with very little else to fall back on. Its Expert Panel warns of ‘existential threats’, notes that artificial intelligence ‘threatens to replace many jobs, not least in fund administration, which currently accounts for a quarter of financial sector employment’, particularly ‘lower-skilled and entry level positions’, and concludes that ‘there is little that Jersey can do to mitigate these risks’. It observes that public spending has risen by 33% since 2018, ‘deepening the dependence on the financial sector’. Statistics Jersey‘s figures for 2025, published in October, show what that dependence looks like when the engine falters, with the economy contracting by 1.7%, led by a 4.8% fall in financial and insurance activities, while the economy outside finance grew by just 0.2%. Time to Win was written before those figures and describes a sector still growing in absolute terms, and one year does not make a trend, but it shows how quickly that can change.
The panel itself makes the point I want to make, in a different context. Explaining why Jersey’s finance industry has weathered past shocks, it says that the sector’s ‘particular strength has been its diversity’ and that ‘this diversification has provided resilience’.
That is exactly right, and it is as true of an island as it is of a finance centre. An economy with one dominant engine can run very fast, as Jersey’s has for sixty years, but when that engine misfires, as every engine eventually does, there is little else to keep the Island moving. Time to Win can make that engine more efficient. It cannot, by itself, give Jersey a second one.
Jersey has been here before, in reverse. When Colin Powell, the Island’s economic adviser from 1969, published his Economic Survey of Jersey in 1971, he estimated that tourists’ expenditure accounted for 52% of the Island’s domestic income, against 9% for banking and other commercial activities, and warned that those figures showed ‘the extent to which the Island is dependent on tourism, the narrowness of the economic base, and the potential vulnerability of the economy’. Today Statistics Jersey’s figures put finance at 44% of GVA, and whilst the two measures are not the same, the shape is, with one engine carrying the Island.
Powell’s warning was that ‘prosperity is a tender plant; too often pruned, too little sustenance, or too much interference and it can easily wither’, and that ‘the process of decline once started is extremely difficult to correct’.
Our industry knows the truth of that better than any, and Time to Win is right to be determined that finance never has to learn it, but the lesson belongs to the whole Island, not to one sector.
What Islanders are telling us.
Time to Win measures success in output, tax and market share, and on those measures Jersey has done remarkably well, with the report noting that real income per person has risen from around £7,800 to £65,800 since the sector emerged in the 1960s, against £40,157 in the UK. Statistics Jersey also measures something different, which is how Islanders’ lives actually feel, and that picture is less comfortable.
Its Better Life Index, published in March and following the OECD’s framework, ranked Jersey 28th of 41 countries for overall wellbeing, below the UK and France and slightly below the OECD average. Jersey ranked in the top ten for community, personal safety and health, which is something to be genuinely proud of, but 34th of 41 for life satisfaction and 34th for work-life balance, with one employee in seven working 50 hours or more a week, against fewer than one in ten in the UK.
Housing took almost a quarter of household disposable income, the fourth highest share of the 41, and once Jersey’s cost of living is accounted for, disposable income per person was below the OECD average. Statistics Jersey’s own summary is that Jersey ‘performs worse, on a relative basis, across the quality of life domain compared with the material conditions domain’.
The Jersey Opinions and Lifestyle Survey, published in December, tells the same story in plainer terms. Adults in the UK reported higher life satisfaction, a stronger sense that their lives are worthwhile and greater happiness than adults in Jersey, with the gaps widest among women, and anxiety was higher here. Three households in ten found it difficult to cope financially, and more than a third could not afford a week’s holiday away from home.
I do not quote these figures to score a point, and nobody should read them as a criticism of any one Government, because they have been many years in the making. I quote them because an economic strategy is only ever a means to an end, and the end is a good life for the people who live here.
An Island that has grown wealthy on paper while its people report lower life satisfaction than adults in the UK has not finished the job, and no amount of competitiveness in one sector will finish it alone.
Any entrepreneur will tell you that if your customers are not satisfied, your business will not succeed for long, however healthy the accounts look in the meantime, and I think it helps to look at an island in the same way. Jersey has two sets of customers, the people who live here and the people who choose to visit, and they are not only our industry’s customers but the whole Island’s. On the evidence, both are telling us the same thing. Islanders’ life satisfaction ranks 34th of 41, while visitors, who rate Jersey highly for almost everything else, scored value for money lower than any other attribute Visit Jersey’s exit survey measures, at 3.5 out of 5 in the summer of 2025. Neither is saying that Jersey is a poor product. Both are saying that what it costs to live here, or to stay here, is not matched by what they feel they get back.
In any business, a verdict that clear from its customers would trigger a change programme, with a business case written in black and white setting out what is wrong, what will be done about it, what it will cost, who owns it and how success will be measured. That is what I have not yet seen for the Island as a whole. The evidence is collected, published and, I am sure, read, but listening is not the same as acting, and until what both of the Island’s customers are saying is turned into a business case for change, they will simply keep telling us the same thing.
The Nordic countries, three of which take the top three places in Statistics Jersey’s Better Life Index comparison, are often held up as proof that people can be happy despite high taxes, and I am not suggesting Jersey should copy their tax rates, because low tax is, and should remain, one of this Island’s real strengths. The World Happiness Report’s own analysis points somewhere more useful, finding that what matters is less how much government spends than what people feel they receive for it, and that what sets those countries apart is trust in institutions that are ‘able to deliver what they promise’. Customers judge value, not price alone, and trust is earned by delivery, which is worth remembering on an Island that ranked last of 41 for civic engagement, measured by turnout of 41.6% at the 2022 election.
Time to Win, the other way round.
Here is a thought experiment I have found useful. Time to Win is a very good report about an industry that, quite rightly, measures its success in financial output, and every one of its headline numbers is financial, from two jobs in five and £6 in every £10 of tax to output per worker nearly three times the rest of the economy. It has been handed to a Government whose spending, as the panel notes, has risen by 33% since 2018, and whose draft 2027 Budget accepts that ‘there are limits to how much additional revenue Government can reasonably raise from households and businesses’ and that Government ‘must live within its means’. Put a plan that promises more revenue in front of any organisation under that kind of pressure and it will, quite naturally, be read first and fastest as a plan for revenue. That is not a criticism of anyone. It is simply how incentives work. Now turn it the other way round.
Imagine Time to Win had been written for the Visitor Economy, and that the measure of success was not gross domestic product but something closer to gross domestic happiness, meaning how Islanders feel about their lives and how visitors feel about their stay, and imagine that on that measure our industry contributed three times as much as finance.
I am not claiming that it does, because nobody has measured it, which is rather the point. That report would open with Islanders’ life satisfaction ranked 34th of 41, value for money the lowest score visitors give us, civic engagement last of 41 and three households in ten finding it difficult to cope, and it would describe them, in the panel’s language, as ‘existential threats’. It would observe that Islanders report lower life satisfaction than adults in the UK, that ‘no one has been mandated to own the whole system’, and that ‘doing nothing is not an option’. It would recommend a cross-ministerial group, a test of cumulative cost, a public dashboard and dedicated funding, and nobody would find any of it strange.
The reason the thought experiment matters is that this Government has a customer problem as well as a budget problem, and money for Government does not, on its own, solve a customer problem. More tax revenue funds the public services Islanders rely on, and that matters enormously, but it cannot by itself close a value deficit that visitors and Islanders both describe, or a gap in how happy people feel, and Statistics Jersey’s own Better Life Index makes the point for me, finding that Jersey performs better on material conditions than on quality of life.
The Minister for Treasury and Resources, Alan Maclean, put it better than I could in his foreword to the draft 2027 Budget, writing that ‘higher spending has not always produced better outcomes’ and that ‘value for money is not measured by how much Government spends, but by what Islanders receive in return’.
I agree with every word, and I would add only that what Islanders, and visitors, receive in return is not only public services but the Island itself, its places to eat and drink, its events, beaches and attractions, its routes in and out, and the feeling of a place that is alive, a great deal of which our industry provides.
None of this needs a new law, because Jersey already has one. The Public Finances (Jersey) Law 2019 requires the Council of Ministers to take into account the sustainable wellbeing of Islanders, ‘including the economic, social, environmental and cultural wellbeing’, when it prepares the Budget each year, and Statistics Jersey already publishes the indicators to measure it. What is missing is a Time to Win for that side of the ledger, with the same urgency, the same ownership and the same willingness to invest, and I would argue that the Visitor Economy belongs at the heart of it.
Can Time to Win win without us?
So, can Time to Win win without the Visitor Economy? I want to be precise about why I say our industry is critical to it rather than merely important, because Time to Win itself makes most of the case.
The first reason is connectivity. The report says that ‘connectivity with London is vital for growth’ and commits to investing in an improved flight schedule for business travellers, and its panel calls restoring an 8pm service to London a priority, because in winter a visitor cannot fly in for a full day of meetings and get home the same evening, adding that any subsidy to airlines ‘is likely to be a trivial cost compared to the business that better connectivity could generate’. Only this month, the Minister for External Relations, Senator Ian Gorst, told a Scrutiny panel that ‘the link to Heathrow is critical to our economic future’, along with a later evening rotation all year round, and that if Ports of Jerseyneed financial support to maintain those services, the competitiveness fund is the right place to find it. I agree with all of it. Routes are not run for business travellers alone, though, and they cannot be.
In the first eight months of this year, visitors arriving for leisure outnumbered those arriving on business by more than five to one, and it is largely that leisure demand, built by Visit Jersey‘s destination marketing and served by our hotels, restaurants and attractions, that gives airlines the volume to keep a route flying all year. The 8pm flight a London fund manager needs in January exists, or does not, in large part because of the families who filled the same route in August.
The second is talent. Time to Win wants to keep ‘incentivising talented people to keep coming to Jersey’, and its panel writes of ‘young families drawn to the island way of life’ and recommends ‘an improved cultural and entertainment offer, which would help attract and retain finance professionals, and at the same time strengthen tourism’. The island way of life that draws those families is, in large part, the restaurants, cafés, pubs, events, festivals and attractions our industry provides, and many of them exist at the quality and in the number they do because visitors help to sustain them. Take the visitors away and the Island does not simply lose some tourism, it loses much of the lifestyle it is trying to sell.
The third is the welcome itself. Time to Win says that ‘it is no longer a privilege for clients to operate in Jersey; it is now Jersey’s privilege to host and serve global businesses and investors’, and it asks for a ‘service culture’ and a concierge service that provides ‘a welcoming and effective front door for business new to the Island’. To host and to serve is the language of hospitality, and those are the skills our industry practises every day, because for many of the people Time to Win hopes to attract, a hotel, a restaurant or an arrival at the airport will be their first experience of Jersey.
That suggests a natural division of labour. The introductions, the onboarding and the detail of setting up a financial business are rightly Jersey Finance‘s job, as the panel recommends, and they need a human being at the other end of the phone who understands the industry.
The rest of the welcome, though, the arrival, the evening, the table that has been booked and the sense of what life here would actually feel like, is what the hospitality industry does for a living, and I can think of nobody better placed to deliver it.
Joined up properly, and with the kind of visitor intelligence I argued for in the second article of this series, it would also give Jersey something it has never had, which is a way of knowing which visits go on to become investment, and that kind of connection between industries is exactly what will make this Island thrive.
The fourth is jobs. If the panel is right that AI will hit entry-level and lower-skilled roles in finance hardest, and that there is little Jersey can do about it, then the Island will need industries that can still offer young Islanders a first job, a trade and a route into management without anybody having to leave. Hospitality is delivered in person, here, by people, and AI is far more likely to make it more productive than to make it unnecessary.
The fifth is quality of life. When more than a third of households cannot afford a week away, what the Island offers on its own doorstep matters more, not less, and the Visitor Economy is, in a very real sense, the leisure infrastructure that Islanders use every week. It is also one of the few industries whose success Islanders can see and feel directly, in a busier town, a fuller restaurant or a new route from the airport.
I should also answer, respectfully, one line in the panel’s report, which says that tourism ‘has declined sharply’ and that ‘it is unlikely that Jersey can recapture this tourist activity’. If that means the mass seaside holidays of the 1970s, I agree, and I would not want them back. This year, however, overnight leisure visitors are up 9%, Visit Jersey‘s marketing has driven 47% more referrals to local businesses, and Jet2 is trebling its capacity for next summer. The market has not disappeared. It has changed, towards visitors who spend more and expect more, and Jersey can win it if it chooses to.
To answer my own question bluntly, then, I do not believe Time to Win can win without us. A finance centre that wants a later evening flight to London, more talented people choosing to build their lives here, a reputation for service and a way of life worth relocating for is asking for things that our industry builds and sustains every day, and a plan that relies on all of them while describing the industry that provides them as one in decline has a gap in it that no amount of regulatory reform will close. I do not say that as special pleading, and I am not asking for finance to be given less. I say it because if that gap is real, every Islander, the finance industry included, will pay for leaving it open, and Ministers, the finance industry and our own industry need to sit around the same table and talk about it honestly.
This is not a Jersey challenge alone.
It would be easy to read all of this as one industry body asking for attention, so it is worth saying that the same conversation is happening around the world. Travel and tourism accounted for almost a tenth of the global economy in 2025, according to the World Travel & Tourism Council, and grew faster than the global economy as a whole, yet when an article arguing that tourism should be treated as a platform for the wider economy rather than as a sector was shared on LinkedIn recently, people working in tourism in very different parts of the world described it in their own words as a bridge between people, businesses and cultures, as a form of economic infrastructure, and as something governments still do not take seriously enough.
None of this is new to the OECD, whose framework Statistics Jersey uses for the Better Life Index. In 2017 its members and partners agreed that tourism policy is made difficult by its ‘cross-cutting, multi-level, and fragmented nature’, and set out what ‘whole-of-government policy responses’ would need to do to be effective. That is the same silo problem Time to Win identified in finance, and it is a problem for the visitor economy almost everywhere, not a peculiarly Jersey failing.
What differs is how some of our closest competitors have chosen to respond. The Isle of Man Government, a fellow Crown Dependency and finance centre, adopted a ten-year Visitor Economy Strategy in 2022, approved by Tynwald, which says that the visitor economy is vital to the Island for maintaining and improving its air and sea links, widening leisure opportunities for residents, supporting the growth of other sectors and ‘enhancing the Isle of Man as a place to invest, work, live and relocate to’. It set targets of 500,000 visitors a year and an annual economic contribution of £520 million by 2032, and it reports against them publicly every year, most recently showing 352,000 visitors and, after adjusting for inflation, £433 million in 2025.
I would be careful, though, about how the case for our industry is made, because the language matters more than it might seem. The Cayman Islands Government describes its economy as having ‘two main pillars’, financial services and tourism, which ‘complement each other’, and that sounds like exactly what I am asking for until you see what happens next. Call them pillars and everyone, from economists to Ministers to the public, assumes they should be measured in the same way and then compares them, by output per worker, tax per head and money retained on the island, and on those yardsticks tourism will lose to finance every time. That is precisely what happened in Cayman, where a widely reported economic review in 2024, judging tourism largely on its fiscal and foreign exchange balance, concluded that it was not a key pillar at all and that financial services, in effect, subsidised it. Time to Win, with its comparison of output per worker, invites exactly the same exercise here.
The Isle of Man’s framing is the better one, because it does not ask its visitor economy to be a second finance industry. It treats it as part of the Island’s competitive offer rather than a relic of its past, and values it for what it makes possible, the air and sea links, the leisure, the quality of place and the reasons to invest, work and live there, and judging all of that by finance’s yardsticks would be, to borrow the image from the second article in this series, like weighing flour with a ruler. Our industry is not a rival pillar to be judged on finance’s terms. It is part of the platform that finance, and every other sector, stands on, and Jersey has every ingredient to lead that conversation among small island finance centres rather than follow it, if it chooses to.
Time to Win, for the whole Island.
The good news is that the Common Strategic Policy has already opened the door. Under Priority 3 it commits the Government to ‘apply the Time to Win approach across the wider economy to reinforce growth, diversification, productivity and investment’, and to ‘ensure that the benefits of growth extend beyond financial services’. I could not have asked for a better sentence, and what I am asking for now is that it is taken literally, starting with the Visitor Economy, because Time to Win has already written most of the method.
It would mean a cross-ministerial group with real decision-making power, which is precisely what the panel recommended for finance, and which the Jersey Hospitality Association has asked for since before the election, whether as a committee of its own or as dedicated meetings of the new ministerial group on economic growth.
It would mean someone being tasked, in Time to Win’s own words, with asking whether the cumulative effect of the costs Government controls is making our industry less competitive, from the wage floor and alcohol duty to licensing fees, work permissions and the rules on staff accommodation, rather than each being decided in its own silo.
It would mean measuring the Visitor Economy properly, on its own terms rather than finance’s, with the kind of publicly reported dashboard of performance indicators the panel recommends for finance, and marketing held to account for its return, which is a standard Visit Jersey already sets itself.
It would mean accepting, as the Government already has for finance, that investment in competitiveness pays for itself. Time to Win records almost £31 million in the 2026 to 2029 Budget for the programme’s delivery, around £8 million a year, and says that Government ‘will make the case for increasing the funding if required’. The same logic applies to destination marketing and route development, which is why we have asked that the support our industry already had is not withdrawn just as growth returns.
Above all, it would mean recognising, as Time to Win does for finance, that the Visitor Economy is not one sector competing with others for attention, but a platform on which much of the Island’s connectivity, culture and daily life is built.
Colin Powell saw this more than half a century ago, when he wrote that the Island’s economic activity was ‘essentially a factor of the Island’s “amenity resources”‘, which he described as ‘the special mixture of climate, land, coastline and water’, allied to its favourable tax structure. That is as true of finance today as it was of tourism then, and it is the Visitor Economy that turns those amenity resources into a way of life that people can actually experience.
The new Council of Ministers has made clear that it wants to do this, committing under the same Priority to develop ‘a competitiveness plan for the non-financial services sector’, and I welcome it, but I would be doing our members a disservice if I did not say plainly that, so far, it is an intention rather than a plan. Time to Win for finance came with a programme, an independent expert panel, a delivery roadmap and almost £31 million of funding, and the draft 2027 Budget includes targeted investment to deliver that roadmap, but I can find nothing equivalent in it for applying the same approach to the rest of the economy. A commitment in a strategic policy is a good start. A plan with the Visitor Economy at its heart, and a business case in black and white with an owner, a budget and a date, is what turns it into change.
Conclusion.
Time to Win says that ‘doing nothing is not an option’, and its panel warns that ‘the window for action is narrow’. Both are true, and I hope this Government delivers the report in full, with pace and discipline, because every Islander has a stake in its success, our industry included.
The risk it describes, however, is the risk of an Island that has put most of its eggs in one basket, and the answer to that is not only a better basket. It is a balanced economy with several engines, working in collaboration rather than competition, and judged not only by its output and its tax take but by whether the people who live here feel that their lives are good.
I wrote in February, before the election, that Jersey must win as an Island, not as a single sector. Time to Win is the plan for one sector, and a good one.
What Jersey still needs is the plan for the Island, and when it is written, the Visitor Economy belongs in it not as a rival to finance, measured on finance’s terms, but as part of the platform the whole Island stands on.